A Lee Miscellany
A LEE MISCELLANY PORTRAIT OF MRS. ANNE HILL (CARTER) LEE
Francis A. MacNutt. [We are greatly indebted to Mr. MacNutt for permission to publish this very interesting portrait and to quote his letter. He is a member of the old Rockbridge and Augusta family of the name, to which belonged Alexander McNutt, prominent in Nova Scotia and Governor Alexander G. McNutt, of Mississippi.] GENERAL ROBERT E. LEE [It is the purpose of the editors of this Magazine to confine its pages almost entirely to the printing of source material for Virginia history; but occasionally it seems good to deviate from this rule. A paper on General Lee by such a distinguished soldier as General William Harding Carter finds a suitable place in a magazine published in General Lee’s war-time home. General Carter is a descendant of Giles Carter (1634–1700) of Henrico County, and began his military career in 1864, when a boy of thirteen, he was a mounted messenger in the Federal Army. His career since his graduation at West Point is well known.] Virginia has been especially fortunate in the number of gifted men produced within her borders who have rendered the State and nation services of a high order. The strong families which grew out of the conditions surrounding the Tide Water planters furnished brilliant examples of their school of thought and action but that there was no ban in the old commonwealth upon genius of more modest estate is amply evidenced by the careers of such types as Patrick Henry and General Stonewall Jackson. War for a principle always finds at the forefront the manly men, the gentlemen, who forsaking the allurements of peace go forth to battle that their view of right shall prevail, and out of every war of magnitude there comes some figure to whom all eyes turn in recognition of superior qualities. With the hopes and hearts of the Confederacy ever centered upon him, it required a sturdy frame and a life of well guarded habits to enable Robert E. Lee to bear the burden of hardship and command during the four years of blighting civil war. That he bore it to the last without deviation from the standards of character derived from a long line of distinguished ancestors is the verdict of history. The great value of strong families to any nation makes it peculiarly important that personal characteristics of individuals should be accentuated rather than submerged in the more material story of general success or failure. Memoirs and diaries are usually written without object other than to preserve personal experiences and opinions. They supply the sidelights needful to perfect history and to enable posterity to discern the motives which move men in the lesser as well as in the more important affairs of life. It is to be regretted that such writings seldom become available to historians until the generation to which they pertain has passed. It does not fall to the lot of a single generation to produce many men of the extraordinary qualities and commanding characteristics of Robert E. Lee. When we view the futile efforts of his contemporaries to properly estimate his life work it makes it all the more important that the fragmentary data found in diaries and the by-ways of literature shall be preserved and made available for the historian who will write when all the fires of sectional hatred and distrust shall have been as completely sunk in oblivion as are those of the tory and patriot families of the Revolution. Countless thousands have gazed upon the awe-inspiring mausoleum of Napoleon in the Invalides at Paris with a sense of the very presence of tramping, desolating armies. A century ago all Europe was, as now, an armed camp. Its map had been made and re-made at the whim of the heroic figure who then dominated its affairs. But in the end, his martial destiny, in which he had so long relied, directed his course to Waterloo and the oblivion of the lonely isle of St. Helena. Coming down the intervening years we have the diaries and memoirs of Napoleon’s immediate military family, even the views of his valets, and all have been devoured by a voracious and insatiable reading public. Out of it all there has come a solitary figure unrivalled in technical knowledge of the art of war, who had the gift of arousing and holding the enthusiasm of a nation in arms through all the years of his leadership, and in the end has left the world only a synonym—The Man on Horseback. Another mausoleum of less intrinsic grandeur than that in the Invalides and not so frequented by tourists, marks the resting place of Robert E. Lee, near the village of Lexington in the Blue Ridge Mountains of Virginia. It is impossible to gaze upon this mausoleum without feeling the impress which rightfully comes from the career of one who has not only received the profound recognition of the civilized world for his ability in the profession of arms, but who left an example of honorable conduct, Christian character and model family life which will abide as a heritage with his people so long as children lisp the story of their forebears’ deeds. In studying the cold official archives of wars the student gradually becomes possessed with a desire to learn more of the personality of those who have directed the pawns upon the battlefields. Few writers have failed to make estimates of the relative qualifications of the leaders of the Civil War which by its long continuance and wide-spread area of operations gave ample opportunity for development of those in whom the real light of leadership burned. It is remarkable how accurately the experience of the Revolution was repeated as far as the employment of foreign officers was concerned, for during the four years of gruelling campaigning every important battle of the Civil War was commanded by Americans. Out of sixty important battles and campaigns all but five were commanded on both sides by graduates of West Point. This result, the inevitable logic of battle experience, found the leaders of the two armies without doubt as to the superior qualities of the commanders of the opposing sides. The family name of each continues to be borne upon the Army Register and with the prestige which rightfully flows from distinguished service representatives of this and coming generations may be relied upon for more than yeoman service. The basic foundations of General Robert E. Lee’s character are well set forth in one of his letters to his son, George Washington Custis Lee, when the latter was a cadet at West Point. It has long been one of the traditions that the parent confided his expectations to the son that the latter should stand as well as the father had stood. G. W. C. Lee fulfilled the injunction by graduating at the head of his class, beating his father by one file.
Here, by his own hand, are the springs of action which governed his own career and brought young Robert E. Lee at an early period of his life, to the serious and admiring consideration of his superiors and others high in the councils of the nation. In these days of world-wars we may pause and read, perhaps with profit, something of this American soldier. John Esten Cooke, himself a Virginian of no little merit, says of Robert E. Lee:
General Ethan Allen Hitchcock, a grandson of Ethan Allen, and one of the most remarkable of the many students and writers West Point has produced, frequently mentions Robert E. Lee in his diary and notes the confidence reposed in him by General Scott during the campaign in Mexico, where Hitchcock served as Inspector General. Here we learn that, “General Scott attributed the fall of Vera Cruz to the skill and activity of Captain Lee,” and then, under date of March 20, 1846, follows this remarkable entry:
The simply recorded story of an excited and surprised sentinel of the outpost, aiming in haste and firing a large caliber pistol ball between the left arm and body fo a presumed foe. A bit of rust, a stiff lock and a hard pull on the trigger probably served to draw the muzzle far enough to the right to miss the heart—and leave Robert E. Lee to command the army of Northern Virginia during four years of titanic war, and in final defeat to give his people and example of Christian fortitude and ideal endeavor unparalleled in all history. General E. D. Keyes, who kept a record of events during the many years of his service, including those spent in the military family of General Winfield Scott, has left us this estimate of Robert E. Lee: He passed the four years of his cadetship without a single mark of demerit, and during my long acquaintance with him I never heard him accused of an act of meanness, tyranny or neglect of duty. His nature was genial and sociable, and he would join freely in all the sports and amusement proper to his age. He was exempt from every form and degree of snobbery, which is a detestable quality that appears most often among people whose theories of government presume an absolute equality. To whatever station he was ordered, however secluded or unhealthy it might be, he would go to it with cheerfulness. Every kind of duty seemed a pleasure to him, and he never intrigued for promotion or reward. Nevertheless, no man could stand in his presence and not recognize his capacity and acknowledge his moral force. His orders, conveyed in mild language, were instantly obeyed, and his motives were universally approved. In all the time in which I observed his conduct I was true to my own antecedents. I was a Northern man, and no word dropped from my lips or was shed from my pen that did not testify to my origin and proper allegiance. I will not deny that the presence of Lee, and the multiform graces that clustered around him, oftentimes oppressed me, though I never envied him, and I doubt if he ever excited envy in any man. All his accomplishments and alluring virtues appeared natural to him, and he was free from the anxiety, distrust, and awkwardness that attend a sense of inferiority, unfriendly discipline and censure. It was General Keyes, then Military Secretary to General Scott, who, on April 18, 1861, ushered Colonel Lee into the presence of his old friend and commander for that fateful interview of which neither participant left the slightest record, but during which the command of the Federal Army was generally believed to have been urged upon Colonel Lee, who had not then tendered his resignation from the army. General Keyes records as to General Scott that, “He had an almost idolatrous fancy for Lee, whose military genius he esteemed above that of any other officer of the army.” At various times during the progress of the Civil War there appeared insistent rumors of disagreement between the President of the Confederacy and General Lee. In an address to the survivors of the Army of Northern Virginia in Richmond, Jefferson Davis saved future historians all necessity for research as to this by the statement:
When Henry Clay had failed to reach the political goal for which he had so splendidly campaigned, the Clay Clubs delivered to him an address which may be aptly applied to the case of General Lee and his devoted followers:
The truthful and recorded history of a nation, perpetuating heroic ideals and lofty purposes will endure when triumphal arches and monuments have crumbled to dust and mingled with the ashes of bygone centuries. General Grant, the great soldier who led the armies of the North to final and complete victory, writing from his bed of mortal illness, has set a standard of thought concerning the civil war to which honorable men of all sections may well subscribe, in entire good faith:
WILLIAM HARDING CARTER. ANOTHER LEE LETTER So far as can be ascertained by examination of the printed documents and by inquiry at the leading collections of manuscripts, the subjoined letter of General Robert E. Lee has not previously appeared in print. However, some of the points contained in it will be recognized as having appeared in other utterances of the General’s. A few years after graduation from West Point, the late Mr. Benjamin H. Wright, of Rome, New York, resigned from the army and devoted himself to the profession of civil engineering. He pursued this calling with success, in various parts of the Union and adjacent countries. One of his most notable achievements was the construction of the first railroad in Cuba. At the time of the Civil War he was too old for military service, but did what he could in a civilian capacity. He kept up a voluminous correspondence then and subsequently, with many of the leaders on both sides. It was one of his idiosyncracies, says his daughter, Miss Henrietta H. Wright, of Rome, to draft a letter, then lay it aside for days, weeks or even months, to “season”, after which he would revise it and dispatch it. Finding this letter from General Lee among her father’s papers, Miss Wright treasured it carefully. Recently she began to feel that such a document should not remain in private hands, so consulted several friends, concerning its disposal, amongst others, her attorney, Charles A. Miller, Esquire, of Utica, and Samuel H. Beach, president of the Rome Savings Bank. As a result of these discussions Miss Wright decided to present the letter to the Jervis Library of Rome, and while that institution is providing an adequate place for its safekeeping, Mr. Beach has it in the vaults of his bank. At Mr. Miller’s suggestion and with Miss Wright’s entire approval, Mr. Beach kindly permitted the letter to be seen and copied, and suggested that Miss Wright might have a copy of her father’s letter to General Lee. A call upon Miss Wright elicited the fact that she had found an unfinished draft of a letter from her father to the General, which she graciously permitted to be copied.
Here the draft abruptly ends. Apparently Mr. Wright laid it aside until the following January. Whether he simply completed this letter or wrote an entirely different one cannot now be determined. But the points he wished to raise are clear from the answer of General Lee.
|

